Top Pizza in Bay View Milwaukee


If you're looking for a great slice of cheese, pepperoni, or sausage pizza then this is your lucky day!

Have you been searching for the best pizza in Bay View Milwaukee Wisconsin? If you’re looking for a great slice of cheese, pepperoni, or sausage pizza then this is your lucky day. This post is going to show you where to go get the best in pizza Bay View that’ll be worth your time.

You may have heard the saying that pizza is like sex. When it’s good it’s great, when it’s bad it’s still pretty good. Well, here are a couple of options for the top pizza in Bay View to ensure that your pizza experience is guaranteed to be great! We have our favorite classic pizza styles (Hawaiian* and SMO*), but sometimes we will go with the restaurant’s specialties. After all, they wouldn’t come up with a specialty if they didn’t think it was the top pizza in Bay View!

Whatever toppings you prefer, one of these Bay View spots will deliver (they might actually have delivery, but we recommend dining in).

*We always add pepperoncini for a little extra heat

*Sausage Mushroom Onion for the pizza virgins

top pizza in bay view Milwaukee

Looking for great Pizza? Look No Further: Top Pizza in Bay View Milwaukee

Top Pizza in Bay View Milwaukee

Transfer Pizzeria Cafe

Transfer Pizzeria Cafe has the best Pizza sauce(s) in Milwaukee. I recommend ordering any of the “red sauce” pizzas and then ordering a side of pesto or marinara! Their pesto is nut-free so I really appreciate that and their marinara has tons of garlic in it! We always order their Spinach Artichoke Dip as an appetizer and sprinkle the red pepper flakes on it. And if you still aren’t convinced why you should stop in for a pie, if you visit Transfer during their happy hour (Monday – Thursday 3-6 pm) you will not be disappointed; they have a seasonal tap list & the heaviest wine pours!

Top Pizza in Bay View Milwaukee Top Pizza in Bay View Milwaukee

RELATED:  Best Milwaukee Happy Hours – Our Favorite Food & Drink Deals  


I know they are known for their homemade pasta, but, please, do not hesitate to order their pizza! Tenuta’s is Bay View’s neighborhood spot, that every other neighborhood only wishes it could have! We love their thin crust pizzas; it is saltine-thin, crispy, and just so delicious we could eat it multiple times a week. Tenuta’s is a casual spot in Bay View with a Bar that is perfect for date night or a bigger table for you and all your friends. Their pizza menu is pretty straightforward, nothing over the top, just the perfect cheese, meat, and sauce ratio.

top pizza Milwaukee

Anodyne Coffee Roasters

Anodyne in Bay View wins the award for the, “Best Milwaukee Pizza You Probably Didn’t Know Exists!” for the simple reason that you probably wouldn’t expect some of the best pizza in the city to be served at a coffee shop, but trust me when I say, Anodyne has some of the best tasting & best-looking pizza in Milwaukee! They have a featured Pizza that changes weekly and a full menu with pizza toppings ranging from classic to un-heard of. Regardless if you decide to do classic, spicy, sweet, or veggie you’re going to leave impressed and (most likely) their newest, biggest fan.

top pizza in bay view milwaukee top pizza in bay view milwaukee

Classic Slice

Classic Slice has been serving the best pizza in Bay View since 2007! I urge you to explore Classic Slice’s menu, which is full of high-quality ingredients and interesting specialty options. Customers can also build their own pizza, using literally dozens of cheese, meat (or meatless substitute proteins), veggie options, and crust as a template to craft your perfect pizza. I highly recommend trying one of their specialty pizzas. The “MEATALLICA” is topped with Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, and Meatballs!

Classic Slice Pizza Bay View

Historic Scotty’s Bar & Pizza

Scotty’s Bar & Pizza should be a household name when it comes to delicious pizza! Their homemade pizza has the absolute best cracker-thin crust that will have you drooling from the minute it comes out of the oven! However, aside from those who are referred to the South Side bar by word of mouth, proximity, or interest, the modest corner tap with a kitchen is something of an enigma to the city at large. We were lucky to be tipped off to this place a few years ago for the fish fry but, now we go for the pizza! Every time we visit here we are reminded some of the most underrated pizzas can be found in the most underrated places.


We were inspired to write this because National Pizza Day (February 9th) is just around the corner. It may not be a national holiday, but that doesn’t mean you can’t celebrate by getting a pie from one of these places. You can be sure that Caleb and I will be enjoying one! Or any day of the week for that matter! Cheers!

Have you tried our favorites? What is your go-to pizza topping? Feel free to comment below or connect with us on the House Fur instagram. 

Join the Conversation

  1. I can imagine this post was really difficult to research for 😉 I love Tenuta’s! Great post 🙂

    1. Ren Lenhof Author says:

      Oh, it was just so hard! 😉 Thanks for reading!!!

  2. I think we’re going to have pizza this valentine’s day instead of typical formal date. Pizza and movie date night 🙂

    1. Ren Lenhof Author says:

      Oh! that sounds amazing! Have an amazing Valentine’s Day!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

House Fur © Copyright 2021. All rights reserved.